American Idol drama ...

🤖 AI Summary

No AI summary has been generated for this thread yet.
I think I must be the only person who voted for Nikki McKibbin last year. I liked her and I thought the judges were unnecessarily cruel to her. Her voice is better than someone like Britney and I thought she had much more "star" potential than Justin ever did.

As for this year, I just don't see Clay winning. He's WAY too over the top and Simon's comment about his theatrics was right on (for once). He totally should be on Broadway somewhere. He's not an American Idol.
 
I missed the show last night (as always)

How did it go? I heard Simon was cruel to Clay!!!!

I wanted to see it too... the BeeGees... that must have been a great show last night.

Fill me in... PLEASE. 😀
 
i thought it was a good show....the BeeGees have so many good songs (i felt so old when i knew all of the songs!!) anyway, everyone did really good. in my opinion, kim wasn't that great and as usual i didn't like Josh. Clay was good, except for the pelvic thrusts he was doing on "Grease"....i was gettin' sick!! LOL Rueben as always, was the best. Simon did bust on Clay. then he told Rueben that this competition would not be the same without him. I AGREE! If america votes right, it should be kim and josh in the bottom two and josh should go....but after last weeks show, who knows whats gonna happen!

**MICHELLE**
 
The show was a little disappointing to me last night...The Bee Gees had SO MANY excellent songs, but they didnt choose all of their best. Simon loved Clay's first performance...he sang "To Love Somebody" and did a fantastic job. But his second song was "Grease" and I just knew that Simon would pan him...he doesnt go for those cutesy types of performances, so he thought it was "absolutely horrible" (insert English accent here...lol) While I did agree that Clay could have picked a better song, he was far from horrible.
Josh also sang To Love Somebody and Jive Talkin..he was alright but Im still not feeling him....the country vocie just doesnt do it for me. However, the judges did like him last night.
Kim Locke wasnt great last night either...she sang I Just Want To Be Your Everything and Emotions. I love the song I Just Want to be Your Everything, but I didnt enjoy her version of it. She sang Emotions well, but it was more like the Destiny's Child version of the song. She has had better nights.
I have to say that Ruben was the best of the 4 last night. He sang Nights on Broadway and How Can You Mend a Broken Heart...2 excellent songs and he sang both beautifully!!!
I did call in to vote last night and I have to say that it was next to impossible to get through for both Clay and Ruben for the entire 2 hours that the lines were open. I have a feeling that either Josh or Kim will go tonight. But then again, nothing surprises me after last week lol
One more thing...I was disappointed that nobody sang How Deep is Your Love!!!

Randi (FreestyleGal)
 
Randi, yes, i was also disappointed that no one sung "how deep is your love". they definitely did not choose the more popular BeeGees songs last night. Oh well!!

**MICHELLE**
 
El Boricua.I think the final 2 will be Clay and Ruben...it's anyone's guess as to who will win!

Randi (FreestyleGal)
 
Interesting I had the feeling it would be those 2 but I like Kimberly she is gorgeous!!!
 
Now... this is what I'm talking about. :lol

I feel like I saw the whole show, thank you so much. 😉

wow, no one sang how deep is your love???

That is surprising.

(don't feel old Michelle... I would have been singing right along with you :mdance)

Gina
 
Kim is very talented too....I think she will go very far!!! I cant wait for it to be 8:30 already so we can find out who is going home tonight!!!

Randi (FreestyleGal)
 
You cant know that for sure Mike...everyone was so sure about Tamyra last yr and look what happened. I'll be happy with either Ruben or Clay winning!!!

Randi (FreestyleGal)
 
Trenyce was on The Waybe Brady show the other day, and she said she thinks Clay will win...he has more fans that you can imagine!! I am really rooting for him!! But it's a tough call this year because the talent has been so much better!

Randi (FreestyleGal)
 
I KNOW IT HAS....BUT ONLY ONE WILL REMAIN STANDING....INSPITE OF THE CHOICE, THEY ALL GET DEALS ANYWAY. I WILL DEFINITELY BUY RUBEN, CLAY'S AND KIM LOCKE'S ALBUMS.
 
Ok....and now the REAL competition begins with the 3 finalists who truly deserve to still be there...Clay, Ruben, and Kim!!!!

Rumor has it that Oprah Winfrey will be the guest judge next week..god only knows why lol....I dont know if there will be a particular theme or what.

Loved the Bee Gees medley tonight....those are the songs they should have sung last night!!!!! Kim should have sang If I Cant Have You or A Woman In Love!!!! And Clay should have sang Too Much Heaven!!!

Randi (FreestyleGal)
 
I heard it on KTU actually...but I cant confirm whether it's 100 percent true or not.

Randi (FreestyleGal)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top