I'll start it out.
21,000+ posts
Ugly logo
and it's run by a jerkoff named Kenny Guido
versus CF.com
628,000 posts (pruned from 800,000+)
No Logo
and it's run by its members
CF was gone for a year to give NewYorkFreeStyle.com time to catch up, but still only has 20,000 posts. HMMMM...